From china-industrial-economics-skills
Routes manuscript work for 《中国工业经济》 from topic selection through rebuttal. Use when deciding which cie-* sub-skill to invoke next or when sequencing a paper through this journal's empirical engineering workflow.
How this skill is triggered — by the user, by Claude, or both
Slash command
/china-industrial-economics-skills:cie-workflowThe summary Claude sees in its skill listing — used to decide when to auto-load this skill
这是路由器,不替代任何专用 skill。它告诉你**当前阶段该用哪个 cie-* skill**。
这是路由器,不替代任何专用 skill。它告诉你当前阶段该用哪个 cie-* skill。
默认假设:目标是 CSSCI 产业经济实证顶刊《中国工业经济》(中国社会科学院工业经济研究所主办,月刊)。本刊的标志是实证工程化——办刊理念"理论顶天,实践立地",要求识别干净、稳健性做满、机制+异质性齐备、政策含义可落地。基础事实见 resources/journal-profile.md。
| 当前症状 | 下一个 Skill |
|---|---|
| 不确定够不够格、对不对口(理论太重?偏管理?) | cie-fit-positioning |
| 选题模糊 / 没有干净政策冲击或特征事实 | cie-topic-selection |
| 文献只堆近年回归、没述评不足 | cie-literature-review |
| 政策细节、试点名单、时点讲不准 | cie-institutional-background |
| 实证只有 OLS / TWFE,未回应交错处理偏误 | cie-did-identification |
| 有主结果没机制,或只会三步中介 | cie-mechanism |
| 异质性只切"东中西"一刀 | cie-heterogeneity |
| 稳健性单薄,一问就塌 | cie-robustness |
| 表格列数过多 / 只报显著性不报量级 | cie-tables-figures |
| 政策建议是"加强完善推进"四件套 | cie-policy-implication |
| 准备投稿,需要体例与系统 checklist | cie-submission |
| 收到外审意见,需要写回复 | cie-rebuttal |
cie-fit-positioning — 先判断匹配度,别把理论文/案例文硬投实证刊cie-topic-selection — 政策准实验 / 企业行为 / 产业组织 / 数字经济cie-literature-review — 述评不足,体现前沿性cie-institutional-background — 政策细节、时点、试点名单讲准cie-did-identification — 多期 DID / event-study(平行趋势+安慰剂+异质性稳健估计,强制)cie-mechanism — 分渠道 / 调节,慎用三步中介cie-heterogeneity — 多维切分 + 经济含义cie-robustness — 本刊招牌:稳健性"军备竞赛"cie-tables-figures — 主表后必有经济量级解读cie-policy-implication — 可操作政策含义cie-submission — 投稿前 preflight(页下注、实引、投稿系统、数据代码)cie-rebuttal — 外审 / R&R 后cie-did-identificationcie-mechanism(编委对其有保留,见江艇 2022)cie-robustnesscie-tables-figurescie-fit-positioning 就动笔——它最常救稿(避免投错门)cie-rebuttal 在正文未修订前生成回复按本刊"实证工程化"分轴自检,任一轴亮红灯优先回到对应 cie-* skill,而非顺序往后推。
【对口度】高/中/低 → 红转 cie-fit-positioning
【选题硬度】特征事实+干净冲击 → 弱转 cie-topic-selection
【制度细节】文件/时点/名单可核 → 缺转 cie-institutional-background
【识别洁净】平行趋势+安慰剂+交错稳健 → 缺转 cie-did-identification
【机制成色】分渠道/调节(非三步中介) → 红转 cie-mechanism
【异质性】≥3维+组间检验 → 薄转 cie-heterogeneity
【稳健军备】度量/样本/识别/排除解释四块 → 缺转 cie-robustness
【图表/政策/投稿】量级解读/可落地/页下注实引数据代码 → 缺转对应 skill
【综合判定】可投 / 待修 <最弱环>
示意稿件:以分批的"智能制造试点示范"为冲击,工企+上市公司样本。按路由顺序自检:cie-fit-positioning(政策准实验→留投)→ cie-topic-selection(补特征事实图)→ cie-institutional-background(分批列时点名单)→ cie-did-identification(交错 DID:Bacon+CS+事件研究图)→ cie-mechanism(弃三步中介,估 X→M)→ cie-heterogeneity(三维+组间检验)→ cie-robustness(剔同期样本、PSM-DID、TFP 多法)→ cie-tables-figures → cie-policy-implication → cie-submission。
cie-did-identification。cie-mechanism(援引江艇 2022)。cie-heterogeneity / cie-robustness。cie-rebuttal(先改正文)。cie-topic-selection 阶段即劝退或换设计。各 cie-* skill 内的数字阈值均为经验锚点,正式体例以编辑部最新稿约为准。npx claudepluginhub brycewang-stanford/awesome-journal-skills --plugin china-industrial-economics-skillsJudges manuscript fit for China Industrial Economics journal based on empirical engineering criteria, and suggests alternative journals for theory-heavy, management, or finance papers.
Encodes the fit, framing, abstract/keyword house style, official-submission re-check, and desk-reject heuristics for 《产业经济研究》 (Industrial Economics Research), a Chinese CSSCI journal. Guides manuscript targeting for industrial-organization, competition policy, and digital transformation topics.
Routes manuscript workflow from topic selection through rebuttal for 《财经研究》 (Journal of Finance and Economics). Dispatches to the correct cfe-* sub-skill based on current stage or bottleneck.