From china-industrial-economics-skills
Provides precise policy/institutional background details (document names, dates, pilot batches, city lists, assignment rules) for China Industrial Economics manuscripts to avoid desk rejection.
How this skill is triggered — by the user, by Claude, or both
Slash command
/china-industrial-economics-skills:cie-institutional-backgroundThe summary Claude sees in its skill listing — used to decide when to auto-load this skill
- 制度背景段只说"近年来国家高度重视…",无文件、无时点
本刊实证工程化,识别的合法性几乎全押在制度细节上。处理时点、处理对象、分配规则讲不准,后面所有 DID / event-study 都站不住。这也是高频拒稿/退修点。
cie-robustness)cie-did-identification)把制度背景按"可不可核查、接不接识别"分级,红格即高危退稿点。
| 要素 | A 级(可核查、接识别) | C 级(高危) |
|---|---|---|
| 政策文件 | 全称+发文机关+文号+时间 | "国家出台了相关政策" |
| 执行时点 | 逐批落地时点,与数据期对齐 | 时点含糊 / 用发文年当处理年 |
| 处理对象 | 城市/行业/企业名单 + 来源 | "部分地区""一些企业" |
| 分配规则 | 遴选标准并接平行趋势论证 | 只字未提,外生性无依据 |
| 政策内容 | 对应理论机制的具体环节 | 罗列文件原话不接机制 |
本刊把识别合法性押在制度细节上,C 级要素是高频退修/拒稿触发点;具体尺度以编辑部最新审稿标准为准。
示意冲击为"智能制造试点示范",常见误区是当成一次性政策。规范写法:
cie-robustness),并在 event-study 中检验平行趋势。cie-did-identification)。【政策】<文件名 + 发文机关 + 时间>(可核查 √ / 待核实)
【处理时点】<单一 / 分批:批次+时点>
【处理对象】<范围 + 名单来源>
【分配规则】<外生论证强 / 弱 → 需 PSM/趋势控制>
【接识别】交错 □ 预期效应 □ 平行趋势风险 □
【下一步】cie-did-identification
npx claudepluginhub brycewang-stanford/awesome-journal-skills --plugin china-industrial-economics-skillsDrafts and revises the institutional-background section of Management-World manuscripts with a four-paragraph structure, policy timeline tables, and reviewer-ready context.
Transforms vague policy implications in China Industrial Economics manuscripts into actionable recommendations with specific actors, nodes, and actions tied to empirical findings and heterogeneity.
Guides submission to 《中国工业经济》(China Industrial Economics) — top journal for industrial organization, firm behavior, and policy evaluation. Covers DID/event-study compliance, mechanism testing, heterogeneity analysis, robustness checks, and policy implications.