From jibs-skills
Plans revisions and drafts the point-by-point response letter for a JIBS revise-and-resubmit, prioritizing the area editor's letter and executing cross-national measurement, CMV, and endogeneity work.
How this skill is triggered — by the user, by Claude, or both
Slash command
/jibs-skills:jibs-rebuttalThe summary Claude sees in its skill listing — used to decide when to auto-load this skill
- You received a JIBS major/minor revision and need a plan plus a response letter
A JIBS response letter documents revisions that already exist; do not promise work you have not done. JIBS R&Rs are substantive and multi-round — budget real new analysis (a new estimator, an invariance test, an instrument), not just rhetoric.
The area editor's letter is the priority map. Group reviewer comments under the editor's integrated themes; lead your plan with the concerns the editor elevated (typically: phenomenon/contribution, cross-national measurement, CMV, and endogeneity). Where two reviewers conflict, adjudicate transparently and defer to the editor's framing.
【Editor-priority map】ranked themes from the area-editor letter ...
【Per-comment plan】comment → revision (section/page/table) → status ...
【Measurement/CMV/endogeneity work】executed analyses + editorials cited ...
【Conflicts resolved】reviewer A vs. B adjudication ...
【DART/DAS update】 ...
【Word-budget check】revision still within inclusive limit ...
【Response letter】point-by-point draft ...
npx claudepluginhub brycewang-stanford/awesome-journal-skills --plugin jibs-skillsDrafts the point-by-point response letter for a Journal of Management R&R, handling reviewer conflicts, editor-first strategy, and 50-page limit compliance.
Plans and drafts point-by-point response letters for JAMS R&R revisions, prioritizing editor concerns and strengthening theoretical/managerial contribution.
Drafts point-by-point response-to-reviewers for Journal of Management Studies R&R, handling reviewer conflicts and theoretical contribution reframing.