From jcr-skills
Explains double-anonymized review, co-editor/AE/reviewer structure, decision letters, and interdisciplinary expectations at Journal of Consumer Research.
How this skill is triggered — by the user, by Claude, or both
Slash command
/jcr-skills:jcr-review-processThe summary Claude sees in its skill listing — used to decide when to auto-load this skill
- You want to know what to expect after submitting to JCR
JCR uses double-anonymized (masked) peer review: reviewers do not see author identity and authors do not see reviewers'. Editorially, the journal is led by an Editor in Chief (Oleg Urminsky, Chicago Booth, term Jan 1, 2025 – Dec 31, 2028) with Co-Editors who handle full manuscript portfolios, Associate Editors, an Editorial Review Board, and ad hoc reviewers. The active co-editor roster is time-sensitive — 待核实; confirm the current masthead at consumerresearcher.com. The precise desk-assignment/routing mechanism is 待核实 (the official pages do not describe a fixed departmental area-editor routing); in practice a co-editor takes the manuscript and assigns reviewers.
JCR's identity as a multi-disciplinary journal shapes the review: you may draw reviewers from psychology, anthropology, sociology, economics, marketing, or statistics, and an experimental paper and a CCT paper are held to the same conceptual bar — advancing, deepening, or repudiating theory about consumption — even though their evidentiary standards differ.
jcr-topic-selection / jcr-contribution-framing.【Decision type】reject / desk reject / R&R
【Editor's priorities】the decisive concerns, in order
【Reviewer map】each point → stage → jcr-* skill
【Genre standard】experimental process evidence / CCT trustworthiness
【Transparency conditions】data/materials/code required at revision?
【Next step】jcr-rebuttal (if R&R) or re-scope (if reject)
npx claudepluginhub brycewang-stanford/awesome-journal-skills --plugin jcr-skillsRoutes manuscript work from topic selection through rebuttal for a Journal of Consumer Research (JCR) paper. Invokes specialized jcr-* sub-skills based on current bottleneck.
Explains the Journal of Marketing double-anonymized review process, coeditor structure, substantive evaluation bar, and how to read decision letters. Does not draft responses.
Describes the JMR review process stages including desk rejection, domain routing with EIC+Coeditor model, double-anonymized review, and interpreting decision letters. Useful before submission or after receiving a decision.