agent-session-forensics

Agent Session Forensics

When To Use

• Agent session ended mid-tool-call or cannot resume.
• Tool call appears in assistant turn but no corresponding result turn follows.
• Need to correlate tool calls, tool results, and timing metadata.
• Diagnosing slow LLM calls, duplicate user turns, or malformed results.
• Debugging experimental MCP data-layer sessions.

Requirements / Checks

• Locate session directory and history files before editing anything.
• Prefer read-only inspection first.
• Have jq or equivalent JSON tooling available.
• Ask before modifying, truncating, or deleting any session or history file.

Workflow

1. Inventory session files — find metadata, current history, rotated previous history, and related subagent histories.

2. Count and list last turns:

   jq 'length' history.json                                      # total messages
   jq '.[-10:] | .[] | {role, stop_reason}' history.json        # last 10 turns
   jq '.[] | select(.role=="assistant") | .tool_calls[].id' history.json  # tool call IDs
   jq '.[] | select(.role=="user") | .tool_results[]?.tool_call_id' history.json  # results
   

3. Correlate tool call IDs — every tool_call in an assistant turn must have a matching tool_result in the immediately following user turn. Find the first gap.

4. Check timing for slow calls:

   jq '.[] | select(.timing) | {role, duration_ms: .timing.duration_ms}' history.json
   

5. Identify failure pattern — see table below.

6. Repair (if approved) — write a backup first (cp history.json history.json.bak), then make the smallest possible fix at the last valid correlation boundary.

Common Failure Patterns

Symptom	Likely cause	Repair
Tool call with no result turn	Session interrupted mid-tool	Truncate after last matched pair
Two consecutive user turns	Duplicate message insertion	Remove the duplicate
tool_result with no prior tool_call	Corrupted or manually edited history	Remove orphan result
Empty content on assistant turn	Model returned no text + no tools	Usually safe to truncate
Session loops without progress	Missing result causes re-prompt	Inject minimal synthetic result

Safety Constraints

• Do not edit session JSON without backing up the original first.
• Treat history files as sensitive: prompts, tool arguments, credentials, and file contents may appear.
• Do not infer user intent from stale history when current user instructions conflict.
• Do not repair by deleting broad ranges — find the last valid tool-call/result correlation boundary.

Validation / Done Criteria

• Report the names of every session file inspected.
• Every tool-call ID is accounted for (matched or flagged as unmatched).
• Any proposed repair names the backup path and truncation boundary.
• No session file is mutated without explicit user approval.

References

• references/history-diagnostics.md