idea-feasibility

Idea Feasibility Skill

Used for pre-implementation idea review. The goal is to detect high-risk issues early—such as non-judgeable tasks, unverifiable requirements, or missing constraints—so you avoid rework in the coding phase.

Trigger Conditions

• The user only provides a problem idea and the input/output protocol is not yet stable.
• Constraints or judging rules are unclear (especially for multi-answer or interactive problems).
• Before the team starts implementing sol/brute/generator/validator.

Checklist

1. Judgeability: Is the answer unique? If not, can a checker define valid outputs precisely?
2. Constraint Completeness: Are n_max, value ranges, number of groups, and total scale (e.g., sum_n) clearly defined?
3. Verifiability: Can tests cover boundaries, extremes, and counterexamples? Is generation reproducible (seed + type)?
4. Implementation Feasibility: Are there obviously infeasible or timeout-prone requirements?
5. Interactive Feasibility (if applicable): Is the interaction protocol complete and locally simulatable?

Forbidden Actions

• Do not jump directly into code generation.
• Do not use "to be added later" in place of critical constraints.

Required Output

• decision: go / no_go
• blocking_issues: list of blocking issues that must be fixed
• required_clarifications: key questions to confirm with the user (max 3, prioritized)
• next_actions: minimal action checklist before implementation

Go / No-Go Rules

Return decision=no_go if any of the following is true:

• legality of output cannot be judged deterministically (or checker rules are missing);
• core constraints are incomplete or contradictory;
• reproducible generation/verification cannot be defined;
• interactive protocol is incomplete for interactive tasks.