skill-update

skill-update

Update existing jaan.to skills with specification compliance and documentation sync.

Context Files

• docs/extending/create-skill.md - Skill specification (REQUIRED)
• $JAAN_LEARN_DIR/jaan-to-skill-update.learn.md - Past lessons (loaded in Pre-Execution)
• $JAAN_CONTEXT_DIR/config.md - Current skill catalog
• ${CLAUDE_PLUGIN_ROOT}/docs/extending/language-protocol.md - Language resolution protocol

Input

Skill Name: $ARGUMENTS

The name of the skill to update (e.g., pm-prd-write or just prd-write).

If not provided, list available skills and ask which to update.

---

Pre-Execution Protocol

MANDATORY — Read and execute ALL steps in: ${CLAUDE_PLUGIN_ROOT}/docs/extending/pre-execution-protocol.md Skill name: skill-update Execute: Step 0 (Init Guard) → A (Load Lessons) → B (Resolve Template) → C (Offer Template Seeding)

Language Settings

Read and apply language protocol: ${CLAUDE_PLUGIN_ROOT}/docs/extending/language-protocol.md Override field for this skill: language_skill-update

---

PHASE 0: Git Branch Setup

Create feature branch for updates:

git checkout dev
git pull origin dev
git checkout -b update/{skill-name}

Confirm: "Created branch update/{name} from dev. All updates on this branch."

---

PHASE 1: Analysis (Read-Only)

Thinking Mode

ultrathink

Use extended reasoning for:

• Analyzing existing skill structure
• Planning updates carefully
• Validating against specification
• Ensuring backward compatibility

Questioning Guidelines

Ask up to 7 clarifying questions across Phase 1 if needed.

Skip questions when:

• Information already provided in user input
• Research answered the question
• Context files contain the answer
• Question is redundant with previous answer

Make questions smart:

• Reference user's input: "You said '{X}' — does that mean...?"
• Build on existing skill: "The current skill does Y — should that change?"
• Probe specifics: "What should happen when Z?"

Step 1: Read Existing Skill

Read all files for the skill:

• skills/{name}/SKILL.md - Current skill definition
• $JAAN_LEARN_DIR/{name}.learn.md - Accumulated lessons
• $JAAN_TEMPLATES_DIR/{name}.template.md - Output template (if exists)

Display current structure:

CURRENT SKILL: {name}
────────────────────
Command: /{name}
Name: {name}
Description: {description}

FILES
─────
□ SKILL.md ({line_count} lines)
□ LEARN.md ({lesson_count} lessons)
□ template.md ({exists/missing})

Step 2: Validate Against Specification

Check current skill against docs/extending/create-skill.md:

Frontmatter:

• Has name matching directory
• Has description with purpose and mapping
• Has allowed-tools with valid patterns
• Has argument-hint

Body:

• Has H1 title matching skill name
• Has tagline blockquote
• Has ## Context Files
• Has ## Input
• Has # PHASE 1: Analysis
• Has ## Step 0: Apply Past Lessons
• Has # HARD STOP
• Has # PHASE 2: Generation
• Has ## Definition of Done

Trust:

• Tool permissions are sandboxed

Show compliance status:

SPECIFICATION COMPLIANCE
────────────────────────
✓ Frontmatter: 4/4 fields
✗ Body: 8/9 sections (missing: Step 0)
✓ Trust: sandboxed

Step 2.1: v3.0.0 Compliance Check

Check the skill for v3.0.0 customization system compatibility:

Read and apply V3.1–V3.10 check patterns from: ${CLAUDE_PLUGIN_ROOT}/docs/extending/v3-compliance-reference.md (section: "skill-update: v3.0.0 Compliance Checks", subsections V3.1–V3.10)

Run each check (V3.1 through V3.10) against the skill. Then display:

v3.0.0 Compliance Summary

Display results:

v3.0.0 COMPLIANCE
─────────────────
V3.1 Frontmatter env vars:     ✓ / ✗
V3.2 Context paths:             ✓ / ✗
V3.3 Learning path:             ✓ / ✗
V3.4 Template path:             ✓ / ✗ / N/A
V3.5 Output path:               ✓ / ✗ / N/A
V3.6 Template variables:        ✓ / ✗ / N/A
V3.7 Tech integration:          ✓ / N/A

OUTPUT STRUCTURE COMPLIANCE
───────────────────────────
V3.8.1 ID generation:           ✓ / ✗ / N/A
V3.8.2 Folder structure:        ✓ / ✗ / N/A
V3.8.3 Index management:        ✓ / ✗ / N/A
V3.8.4 Executive Summary:       ✓ / ✗ / N/A

DESCRIPTION BUDGET
──────────────────
V3.9 Description budget:        ✓ / ✗

DISPLAY STRINGS
───────────────
V3.10 Display paths use vars:   ✓ / ✗

VERDICT: v3.0.0 Compliant / Needs Migration / Needs Output Migration / Needs Description Fix / Needs Display Fix

If any check fails (✗):

• Add option [8] to Step 3: "Migrate to v3.0.0"
• If V3.8 checks fail: Add option [9]: "Migrate output structure to ID-based folders"

Step 3: Ask Update Type

"What do you want to change?"

[1] Add/modify questions (Phase 1) [2] Update quality checks (Phase 2) [3] Modify output format (template.md) [4] Add tool permissions [5] Incorporate LEARN.md lessons → SKILL.md [6] Fix specification compliance issues [7] Other (describe) [8] Migrate to v3.0.0 (if v3.0.0 compliance check failed) [9] Migrate output structure to ID-based folders (if V3.8 check failed) [10] Fix description budget (trim Auto-triggers/Maps-to lines, shorten description)

Step 4: Optional Web Research

For options [1], [2], [3], or [7], offer:

"Search for updated best practices? [y/n]"

If yes, use Task tool with Explore subagent:

Task prompt: "Research current best practices for {domain}:
1. Search '{domain} best practices {year}'
2. Search '{domain} checklist {year}'
Return: new practices, updated methodologies, changes since {skill_created_date}"

Step 5: Plan Changes

Based on selected option, plan specific changes:

Option 1 (Questions): Show current questions, propose additions Option 2 (Quality): Show current checks, propose updates Option 3 (Template): Show current template, propose modifications Option 4 (Tools): Show current permissions, propose additions Option 5 (LEARN→SKILL): Map lessons to skill sections:

LEARN.md Section	Incorporate Into
Better Questions	Phase 1 Step 1 questions
Edge Cases	Phase 2 quality checks
Workflow	Process steps + Definition of Done
Common Mistakes	Warnings in relevant sections

Option 6 (Compliance): List missing sections, propose additions Option 7 (Other): Gather details, plan custom changes

Option 8 (Migrate to v3.0.0): Read and apply migration wizard from: ${CLAUDE_PLUGIN_ROOT}/docs/extending/v3-compliance-reference.md (section: "Migration Wizard (v2.x → v3.0.0)"). Offers 4 approaches: Auto-fix all, Interactive, Manual script, Guidance only.

---

HARD STOP - Human Review Check

Show diff preview:

PROPOSED CHANGES
────────────────
File: SKILL.md
───
- old line
+ new line
───

File: template.md (if applicable)
───
- old line
+ new line
───

COMPLIANCE AFTER UPDATE
───────────────────────
✓ Frontmatter: 4/4 fields
✓ Body: 9/9 sections
✓ Trust: sandboxed

"Apply these changes? [y/n/edit]"

Do NOT proceed to Phase 2 without explicit approval.

---

PHASE 2: Update (Write Phase)

Step 6: Update SKILL.md

Apply planned changes while preserving:

• Two-phase workflow structure
• HARD STOP section
• Definition of Done section
• Specification compliance

Step 7: Update template.md (if needed)

If output format changes requested:

1. Update template structure
2. Preserve required metadata section
3. Update placeholders

Step 8: Update LEARN.md

If Option 5 selected (lessons incorporated):

• Add workflow note: "Incorporated into SKILL.md on {date}"
• Keep original lessons for reference

Otherwise, add any new workflow learnings:

• "Updated {section} based on {reason}"

Step 9: Validate Updated Skill

Run full specification check:

• YAML frontmatter complete
• All required sections present
• Two-phase workflow intact
• HARD STOP section exists
• Definition of Done present
• Tool permissions sandboxed

If any check fails, fix before continuing.

Step 10: Preview All Changes

Show final versions of all modified files.

"Write these updates? [y/n]"

Step 10.5: Handle Output Structure Migration (If Option [9] Selected)

Read and apply output structure migration from: ${CLAUDE_PLUGIN_ROOT}/docs/extending/v3-compliance-reference.md (section: "Output Structure Migration (Step 10.5)")

Includes: migration plan display, HARD STOP approval, Step 5.5 insertion, output writing update, template update, and validation checklist.

Step 11: Write Updated Files

If approved:

1. Write SKILL.md to skills/{name}/SKILL.md
2. Write template.md to skills/{name}/template.md (if modified)
3. Write LEARN.md to skills/{name}/LEARN.md

Confirm: "Skill files updated in skills/{name}/"

Step 12: Auto-Invoke Documentation Sync

Run /jaan-to:docs-update {name} to sync:

• docs/skills/{role}/{name}.md

This ensures documentation stays in sync with skill changes.

Step 13: Commit to Branch

Stage and commit updated files:

bash scripts/prepare-skill-pr.sh
git add skills/{name}/ jaan-to/ docs/skills/{role}/{name}.md

prepare-skill-pr.sh regenerates + validates Codex skillpack artifacts and stages adapters/codex/skillpack/.

For full commit message template, read: ${CLAUDE_PLUGIN_ROOT}/docs/extending/git-pr-workflow.md (section: "Step 13: Commit to Branch") Commit message prefix: fix(skill): Update {name} skill

---

PHASE 3: Testing & PR

Step 14: User Testing

"Please test the updated skill in a new session. Here's a copy-paste ready example:"

/{name} "{example_input_based_on_skill_purpose}"

"Did it work correctly? [y/n]"

If issues:

1. Help debug the problem
2. Make fixes
3. Commit fixes
4. Repeat testing

Step 15: Create Pull Request

When user confirms working:

"Create pull request to merge to dev? [y/n]"

If yes, push and create PR. For full PR body template, read: ${CLAUDE_PLUGIN_ROOT}/docs/extending/git-pr-workflow.md (section: "Step 15: Create Pull Request")

git push -u origin update/{name}
gh pr create --base dev --title "fix(skill): Update {name} skill" --body "..."

PR summary must include:

Codex skillpack sync: ✅ generated via scripts/prepare-skill-pr.sh

Show PR URL to user.

If no:

"Branch update/{name} is ready. Merge manually when ready."

---

Step 16: Capture Feedback

"Any feedback on the skill update process? [y/n]"

If yes:

• Run /jaan-to:learn-add skill-update "{feedback}"

v3.0.0 Migration Feedback (if Option 8 was used)

If skill was migrated to v3.0.0, capture migration-specific learnings:

Categories: migration approach effectiveness, missed patterns, template variable adoption, tech stack integration.

Auto-categorize: patterns to compliance checks, edge cases to Step 2.1, workflow to Migration Wizard.

Example:

/jaan-to:learn-add skill-update "Auto-fix missed pattern: `Read(jaan-to/docs/**)` in doc-generation skills."

---

Step 17: Auto-Invoke Roadmap Update

Run /jaan-to:pm-roadmap-update to sync the skill update with the roadmap.

This ensures the roadmap reflects the latest skill changes.

---

Skill Alignment

• Two-phase workflow with HARD STOP for human approval
• Single source of truth (no duplication)
• Plugin-internal automation
• Maintains human control over changes

Definition of Done

• Existing skill files read and analyzed
• Specification compliance validated
• User-selected updates applied
• Passes specification validation after update
• Documentation synced via /jaan-to:docs-update
• User tested and confirmed working
• PR created (or branch ready for manual merge)
• Roadmap synced via /jaan-to:pm-roadmap-update
• User approved final result