refine-tests

Reviews existing test code for conformance to the test-designing-guide and test-writing-guide, then produces a refinement plan.

Mode Check

This skill requires plan mode. Before doing anything else, check the current mode:

• ExitPlanMode is in the deferred tools list → not in plan mode → stop immediately and tell the user:

  "This skill (/refine-tests) requires plan mode. Enter plan mode first: use /plan or press Shift+Tab to toggle."

• ExitPlanMode is NOT in the deferred tools list (i.e., directly callable) → in plan mode → proceed.

Scope Check

This skill is for refining existing tests for conformance to the guides. If the request is out of scope, redirect:

• Adding tests for a new feature or spec change → use /plan-feature instead
• A failing test, or a test that verifies incorrect behavior → use /fix-bug instead

Input

One or more target path arguments. Each may be a single test file, a directory (resolved recursively to its test files), or a glob. Resolve the argument(s) to the concrete set of test files to review before proceeding.

Workflow

Phase 1: Read the Target Tests

Launch Explore agent(s) to read the target test file(s) and the production code they exercise. Reading the production code is necessary to judge layer-appropriateness and structural-vs-spec-based issues.

Phase 2: Conformance Review

Load the test-designing-guide and test-writing-guide skills. Apply all rules that are verifiable from the test code alone — no requirements document is available.

The following sections of test-designing-guide require requirements input or production-design changes and are out of scope:

• Section 5 (requirements coverage / traceability / same-layer witness)
• Section 6 (design-document output format)
• Section 7 (Testability Assessment — remedies require production-design changes)

Produce a Findings list. Each finding records:

• Location: file path + test method name
• Category: which guide + rule violated, or duplicate test (see Phase 3)
• Concrete proposed change

Phase 3: Duplicate Detection

Compare the target test files against each other and against other tests in the same test class.

A true duplicate has both of the following in common with another test:

• Same condition — identical setup / input
• Same assertion — identical observation / expected value

Do NOT flag tests that share only one:

• Different condition → not a duplicate
• Same condition but different assertion → not a duplicate

For each true duplicate pair, append a Finding to the Findings list from Phase 2:

• Proposed change: delete the redundant test (the less accurately named one) and keep the more accurately named one. Name both explicitly.
• Do NOT propose merging same-condition tests into a single multi-assert test.

Phase 4: Review

Read the critical test files. Confirm the proposed changes in the Findings list are consistent with each other and that each change preserves what the test verifies. Also cross-check duplicate findings (Phase 3) against conformance findings (Phase 2): a test slated for rename must not also be the redundant side of a duplicate finding.

Phase 5: Write the Plan File

Assemble the plan file with these sections:

1. Context — what is being refined and why
2. Findings — the Phase 2 list (location / rule / proposed change)
3. Refine Workflow — paste the Template from ## Refine Workflow verbatim as the body of this section

Phase 6: Call ExitPlanMode

---

Refine Workflow

Paste the Template below verbatim as the body of the ## Refine Workflow section in the plan file.

Template

### Step 1: Modify Tests

- [ ] Apply the test changes described in the Findings section
- [ ] Run tests with `/run-tests` and confirm **all pass**

### Step 2: Refactoring

- [ ] Resolve diagnostics at warning or higher for each modified file (`mcp__jetbrains__open_file_in_editor` → `mcp__ide__getDiagnostics` → fix, one file at a time; use `mcp__ide__getDiagnostics` because the Unity editor compiler does not reflect `.editorconfig` severity settings)
- [ ] Run tests with `/run-tests` and confirm **all pass**
- [ ] Run the Claude Code built-in `/simplify` skill (`Skill({skill: "simplify"})` — not a plugin skill) to apply quality improvements to the modified code
- [ ] Run tests with `/run-tests` and confirm **all pass**
- [ ] Commit all remaining changes to git