From paper-review-system
This skill should be used when the user asks to "审稿", "review paper", "审阅论文", "评审论文", "paper review", "检查论文质量", provides a PDF path for academic review, mentions "学术审稿", "conference review", "期刊审稿", or wants to evaluate an academic paper's quality across multiple dimensions including novelty, technical soundness, experiments, and writing quality. Supports venue-specific review for CVPR, NeurIPS, ICML, ICLR, ECCV, ICCV, ACL, AAAI, KDD, MICCAI and more.
npx claudepluginhub lidapengpeng/paper-review-systemThis skill uses the workspace's default tool permissions.
提供专业的学术论文自动化审稿能力,融合 10 个顶级 CS 会议(CVPR/NeurIPS/ICML/ICLR/ECCV/ICCV/ACL/AAAI/KDD/MICCAI)资深审稿人的审稿方法论。支持按目标会议动态调整评审策略、维度权重和 Checklist 检查。
Generates structured peer-review analyses of academic papers from PDFs or URLs. Assesses methodology, contributions, strengths, weaknesses, and provides feedback. Triggers on review requests or paper links.
Generates structured peer review reports for academic manuscripts, evaluating novelty, methodological rigor, clarity, impact, and ethics. Use when critiquing papers or providing reviewer feedback.
Simulates peer review of computer science academic papers, producing bilingual (English-Chinese) structured reports with 1-10 scores on novelty, methodology, writing quality, presentation, significance, critical weaknesses, and actionable suggestions.
Share bugs, ideas, or general feedback.
提供专业的学术论文自动化审稿能力,融合 10 个顶级 CS 会议(CVPR/NeurIPS/ICML/ICLR/ECCV/ICCV/ACL/AAAI/KDD/MICCAI)资深审稿人的审稿方法论。支持按目标会议动态调整评审策略、维度权重和 Checklist 检查。
相比 v1.0 的关键改进:
--venue 参数动态调整评审策略使用 Paper Parser MCP 将 PDF 转为结构化数据。
模拟资深审稿人的"第一遍速读":
5 个并行 Agent 覆盖评审维度(权重按目标会议调整):
| Agent | 维度 | 关键检查点 |
|---|---|---|
| A | 摘要与动机 + 新颖性 | 研究空白、动机强度、创新性判定 |
| B | 技术正确性 | 公式验证、符号一致性、证明严谨性 |
| C | 实验 + 统计严谨性 | SOTA 对比、公平性分析、error bars、统计检验 |
| D | 写作质量 + 可复现性 | 语法、符号一致、Limitations section |
| E | 相关工作 + 参考文献审计 | 参考文献验证、遗漏引用、引用质量分析 |
检查论文-代码一致性、未披露训练策略。
合并所有阶段结果,包含置信度评分和会议特定评分映射。
通过 --venue 参数自动加载会议审稿策略(详见 references/venue-profiles.md):
| 命令 | 用途 |
|---|---|
/review-paper | 完整审稿(4 阶段 + 速读 + 竞品对比) |
/pre-screen | 快速预筛选(< 1 分钟,量化质量信号) |
/rebuttal | Rebuttal 辅助(逐条回复 + 修改验证) |
references/review-template.md - 评审报告完整模板references/scoring-guide.md - 评分标准和接收建议指南references/venue-profiles.md - 15+ 会议/期刊的审稿策略配置references/venue-review-criteria.md - 各会议 Agent 审稿核心要点精粹(v2.2 新增)scripts/quick-assess.py - Phase 1.5 速读自动化(6 项检查)scripts/check-deps.sh - 依赖安装检查docs/reviewer-perspectives/ 目录包含 10 位顶会资深审稿人的详细方法论(162KB):
01-cvpr-reviewer.md ~ 10-miccai-reviewer.md00-synthesis-and-upgrade-plan.md - 综合分析与升级方案