From jop-skills
Prepares replication and data-access packages for The Journal of Politics conditional acceptance review, including readme, datasets, codebook, and code.
How this skill is triggered — by the user, by Claude, or both
Slash command
/jop-skills:jop-replication-and-data-policyThe summary Claude sees in its skill listing — used to decide when to auto-load this skill
This is JOP's signature skill. JOP does not merely request a deposit — **acceptance is contingent on
This is JOP's signature skill. JOP does not merely request a deposit — acceptance is contingent on replicability. A JOP replication analyst, assigned at conditional acceptance, assesses your materials before publication, and manuscripts that are not replicable are rejected. Build the package as you analyze, not at acceptance.
The JOP analyst's re-run is mechanical: it either regenerates your printed numbers or it does not. Close each common failure before conditional acceptance.
| Failure the analyst will hit | Close it before deposit |
|---|---|
| Script errors on a clean machine | Master script, relative paths, fresh-clone test |
| Numbers drift from the printed table | Regenerate every exhibit from code; re-run end to end |
| Stochastic result will not reproduce | Set and report a seed for every random step |
The AVR-turnout author reaches conditional acceptance and the analyst runs the .zip. On a fresh clone the master script fails because the working directory was hard-coded — tested only on the author's machine. After a relative-path fix it runs, but the turnout estimate prints as +1.79 against the paper's +1.8, a rounding mismatch. The author aligns the table to the script's value, confirms the seed reproduces the bootstrap CI, and the re-run matches the printed page.
【Repository】JOP Dataverse (Harvard) — single .zip staged? [Y/N]
【Reproduces everything?】master script re-runs all results locally? [Y/N]
【Four items】readme + dataset(s) + codebook + code present? [Y/N]
【Versions + seeds】OS/software recorded, seeds set? [Y/N]
【Restricted data?】explanation + access path + synthetic data?
【Next】jop-review-process
../../resources/external_tools.md — reproducibility tooling and qualitative-transparency options (QDR)../../resources/official-source-map.md — JOP data-replication policy, replication analyst, JOP Dataversenpx claudepluginhub brycewang-stanford/awesome-journal-skills --plugin jop-skillsAssembles a data and code replication package for a JPE manuscript to DCAS/JPE Data Editor standards, including README, data, code, and output, for deposit to the JPE Dataverse.
Builds replication packages for AJPS manuscripts with mandatory third-party verification of numerical results.
Guides authors of accepted JOLE papers through assembling a data/code deposit for the JOLE Dataverse Repository, including proprietary-data handling and the AER data-availability policy.