From jeea-skills
Plans and drafts a point-by-point response letter and revision strategy for JEEA manuscript decisions (R&R, major/minor revision). Prioritizes co-editor requests, referee comments, and keeps replication package in sync.
How this skill is triggered — by the user, by Claude, or both
Slash command
/jeea-skills:jeea-rebuttalThe summary Claude sees in its skill listing — used to decide when to auto-load this skill
- A JEEA decision letter arrived (R&R, major/minor revision, or reject-and-resubmit)
JEEA review is single-blind and co-editor-led: the co-editor's letter is the controlling document — it tells you which referee points are binding and which are optional. Resubmission also requires the submitting author to be a current EEA member. Empirical revisions must keep the replication package current because the Data Editor verifies it before formal acceptance. The editorial team works to a fast timeline, so a focused, complete revision is rewarded over a sprawling one. Address the general-interest contribution the co-editor cares about first; subfield minutiae second.
jeea-replication-package).For each referee point, use the same three-move structure so the editor can verify your revision quickly:
Open the letter with a short summary of the major changes, framed against the co-editor's essential requests, before the point-by-point.
Referee 1 wants a structural model; Referee 2 calls the existing model "overbuilt." The co-editor's letter says the empirical contribution is the draw and the model should stay light. The rebuttal follows the co-editor: it trims the model (citing Referee 2), explains to Referee 1 that a fuller structural treatment is a separate paper the editor agreed was out of scope, and points to the leaner model section. The contradiction is resolved by deferring to the controlling document, stated explicitly and politely.
【Co-editor essentials】[the binding requests]
【Major points】[referee → change → location]
【Minor points】[handled]
【Conflicts】[how resolved via co-editor]
【Replication】[package updated for new exhibits? Y/N]
【Membership】[submitting author EEA member for resubmission? Y/N]
【Next step】resubmit via the EEA portal
npx claudepluginhub brycewang-stanford/awesome-journal-skills --plugin jeea-skillsStructures the response-to-referees letter and revision plan for an Economic Journal decision letter (R&R or reject-with-encouragement). Does not redo the analysis; route to other ecj skills for that.
Drafts response-to-referees letters and revision plans for JPE decision letters (R&R or reject-with-encouragement). Structures point-by-point rebuttals and change summaries.
Structures point-by-point response letters and aligned manuscript revisions for REStud referee reports and R&R decisions.