pr-feedback

PR Feedback - Integrate Review Comments

Fetch PR review feedback and add actionable items to the plan. You do the work directly.

Step 1: Identify PR

If PR number provided: Use $ARGUMENTS

Otherwise, detect from current branch:

gh pr view --json number,title,state,reviewDecision

If no PR found for current branch, inform user and exit.

Step 2: Fetch Feedback

Get PR details:

gh pr view --json number,title,body,reviews,reviewDecision,comments

Get inline code comments:

gh api repos/{owner}/{repo}/pulls/{number}/comments --jq '.[] | {path, line, body, user: .user.login}'

Step 3: Parse Comments

Categorize each comment:

Pattern	Category
Review state = CHANGES_REQUESTED	Blocker
"must", "need to", "please fix"	Blocker
"should", "consider", "might"	Suggestion
"why", "what if", "?$"	Question
"nit", "minor", "optional"	Nitpick

Extract actionable items:

For each comment/review body:

1. Check if it requests action
2. Summarize the request
3. Note the author
4. Track file/line if inline comment

Step 4: Present Findings

Display to user:

## PR #123 Feedback

**Status**: CHANGES_REQUESTED by @reviewer

### Blockers (must address)
1. Fix null handling in parseConfig (src/config.ts:42)
2. Add tests for edge cases

### Suggestions
3. Consider caching the parsed config

### Questions (respond or address)
4. Why not use the existing parser?

### Nitpicks (optional)
5. Rename variable for clarity

Ask which to add to plan:

AskUserQuestion:
  questions:
    - question: "Which feedback items should be added to the plan?"
      header: "Select"
      multiSelect: true
      options:
        - label: "All blockers"
          description: "Add items 1-2"
        - label: "Blockers + suggestions"
          description: "Add items 1-3"
        - label: "All items"
          description: "Add everything"
        - label: "Select individually"
          description: "Choose specific items"

Step 5: Update Plan

Add PR Feedback section to .devloop/plan.md:

---

## PR Feedback

PR #123 - @reviewer (CHANGES_REQUESTED)

### Blockers
- [ ] [PR-123-1] Fix null handling in parseConfig
- [ ] [PR-123-2] Add tests for edge cases

### Suggestions
- [ ] [PR-123-3] Consider caching config

---

Add Progress Log entry:

- YYYY-MM-DD: Added N PR feedback items from review

Step 6: Next Steps

AskUserQuestion:
  questions:
    - question: "Feedback added to plan. What next?"
      header: "Action"
      multiSelect: false
      options:
        - label: "Start fixing"
          description: "Work on first blocker"
        - label: "Respond first"
          description: "Reply to questions"
        - label: "Review plan"
          description: "See updated plan"

---

Handling Responses

For questions that need responses (not code changes):

gh pr comment {number} --body "Re: [question]

[Your response]"

After addressing feedback:

gh pr comment {number} --body "Addressed feedback:
- [x] Fixed null handling
- [x] Added edge case tests

Ready for re-review."

---

Quick Reference

Command	Purpose
gh pr view	Get PR details
gh pr view --comments	See all comments
gh api .../comments	Get inline comments
gh pr comment	Reply to PR

---

Example Output

Fetching PR #42 feedback...

Found 5 comments from review by @alice:

BLOCKERS (2):
  1. [src/parser.ts:15] Handle null input
  2. [src/parser.ts:42] Add input validation

SUGGESTIONS (1):
  3. Consider using zod for validation

QUESTIONS (1):
  4. Why a custom parser vs. existing library?

Added 4 items to plan under "PR Feedback" section.