Dev Frontend E2E Testing (Gate 5)

Overview

Ensure all user flows from ring:product-designer have passing Playwright E2E tests across Chromium, Firefox, and WebKit with responsive viewport coverage.

Core principle: If the product-designer defined a user flow, it must have an E2E test. If the user can encounter an error, it must be tested.

<block_condition>

• Untested user flow = FAIL
• No error path tests = FAIL
• Fails on any browser = FAIL
• Flaky tests (fail on consecutive runs) = FAIL </block_condition>

CRITICAL: Role Clarification

This skill ORCHESTRATES. Frontend QA Analyst Agent (e2e mode) EXECUTES.

Who	Responsibility
This Skill	Gather requirements, dispatch agent, track iterations
QA Analyst Frontend Agent	Write Playwright tests, run cross-browser, verify flows

---

Standards Reference

MANDATORY: Load testing-e2e.md standards via WebFetch.

<fetch_required> https://raw.githubusercontent.com/LerianStudio/ring/main/dev-team/docs/standards/frontend/testing-e2e.md </fetch_required>

---

Step 1: Validate Input

REQUIRED INPUT:
- unit_id: [task/subtask being tested]
- implementation_files: [files from Gate 0]

OPTIONAL INPUT:
- user_flows_path: [path to user-flows.md]
- backend_handoff: [endpoints, contracts from backend cycle]
- gate4_handoff: [full Gate 4 output]

if any REQUIRED input is missing:
  → STOP and report: "Missing required input: [field]"

if user_flows_path provided:
  → Load user flows as E2E test scenarios
  → All flows MUST be covered

if backend_handoff provided:
  → Verify E2E tests exercise backend endpoints
  → Verify request payloads match contracts

Step 2: Dispatch Frontend QA Analyst Agent (E2E Mode)

Task tool:
  subagent_type: "ring:qa-analyst-frontend"
  prompt: |
    **MODE:** E2E TESTING (Gate 5)

    **Standards:** Load testing-e2e.md

    **Input:**
    - Unit ID: {unit_id}
    - Implementation Files: {implementation_files}
    - User Flows: {user_flows_path or "N/A"}
    - Backend Handoff: {backend_handoff or "N/A"}

    **Requirements:**
    1. Create Playwright tests for all user flows
    2. Test happy path + error paths (API 500, timeout, validation)
    3. Run on Chromium, Firefox, WebKit
    4. Test responsive viewports (mobile, tablet, desktop)
    5. Use data-testid or semantic role selectors only
    6. Run 3x consecutively to verify no flaky tests

    **Output Sections Required:**
    - ## E2E Testing Summary
    - ## Flow Coverage
    - ## Handoff to Next Gate

Step 3: Evaluate Results

Parse agent output:

if "Status: PASS" in output:
  → Gate 5 PASSED
  → Return success with metrics

if "Status: FAIL" in output:
  → If flow not covered: re-dispatch agent to add missing tests
  → If browser failure: re-dispatch implementation agent to fix
  → If flaky: re-dispatch agent to stabilize tests
  → Re-run E2E tests (max 3 iterations)
  → If still failing: ESCALATE to user

Step 4: Generate Output

## E2E Testing Summary
**Status:** {PASS|FAIL}
**Flows Tested:** {X/Y}
**Happy Path Tests:** {count}
**Error Path Tests:** {count}
**Browsers Passed:** {X/3}
**Consecutive Passes:** {X/3}

## Flow Coverage
| User Flow | Happy Path | Error Paths | Browsers | Viewports | Status |
|-----------|------------|-------------|----------|-----------|--------|
| {flow} | {PASS|FAIL} | {descriptions} | {X/3} | {X/3} | {PASS|FAIL} |

## Backend Handoff Verification
| Endpoint | Method | Contract Verified | Status |
|----------|--------|-------------------|--------|
| {endpoint} | {method} | {fields} | {PASS|FAIL} |

## Handoff to Next Gate
- Ready for Gate 6 (Performance Testing): {YES|NO}
- Iterations: {count}

---

Severity Calibration

Severity	Criteria	Examples
CRITICAL	User flow completely broken, data corruption	Transaction fails, user data lost, checkout blocked
HIGH	Missing user flow tests, flaky tests, browser failure	Untested flow from product-designer, test fails intermittently
MEDIUM	Error path gaps, viewport issues	Missing error handling test, mobile viewport untested
LOW	Selector improvements, test organization	Non-semantic selectors, test file structure

Report all severities. CRITICAL = immediate fix. HIGH = fix before gate pass. MEDIUM = fix in iteration. LOW = document.

---

Anti-Rationalization Table

See shared-patterns/shared-anti-rationalization.md for universal anti-rationalizations. Gate-specific:

Rationalization	Why It's WRONG	Required Action
"Unit tests cover the flow"	Unit tests don't test real browser interaction.	Write E2E tests
"Only Chromium matters"	Firefox and Safari have different behavior.	Test all 3 browsers
"Happy path is enough"	Users encounter errors. Test error handling.	Add error path tests
"CSS selectors are fine"	CSS changes with refactors. Use semantic selectors.	Use roles and testids
"Product-designer flows are suggestions"	Flows define acceptance criteria. Cover all.	Test all flows
"Test is flaky, skip it"	Flaky tests indicate real instability.	Fix the test

---