Review content for pedagogical alignment including Bloom/Marzano taxonomy levels, DUA compliance, indicator coverage, and backward design. Trigger on: revision pedagogica, pedagogical review, taxonomy check, DUA audit, alineamiento pedagogico, backward design. Validates that every activity targets the correct cognitive level, meets DUA 2+ adaptation threshold, and follows backward design from objectives through assessment to activities. Gate G1 prerequisite.
From scribanpx claudepluginhub javimontano/mao-scriba --plugin scribaThis skill is limited to using the following tools:
evals/evals.jsonreferences/pedagogical-review-criteria.mdEnables AI agents to execute x402 payments with per-task budgets, spending controls, and non-custodial wallets via MCP tools. Use when agents pay for APIs, services, or other agents.
Compares coding agents like Claude Code and Aider on custom YAML-defined codebase tasks using git worktrees, measuring pass rate, cost, time, and consistency.
Designs and optimizes AI agent action spaces, tool definitions, observation formats, error recovery, and context for higher task completion rates.
Pedagogy without verification is wishful thinking. Every activity must prove its alignment — backward from assessment, upward through taxonomy, outward through inclusion.
Systematically validate that editorial content meets pedagogical quality standards across four dimensions: taxonomy alignment (Bloom/Marzano), DUA compliance, indicator coverage, and backward design coherence. This review exists because pedagogically misaligned content teaches at the wrong cognitive level, excludes learners who need alternative representations, or disconnects assessment from instruction — all invisible defects that only surface when students fail to learn.
| Input | Source | Required | Description |
|---|---|---|---|
| Editorial unit | project/units/ | Yes | The unit under review with activities and DZ-ref tags |
| Matriz A&S | project/matriz-as/ | Yes | Expected taxonomy levels per destreza |
| Taxonomy mapping | references/taxonomy-mapping.md | Yes | Bloom/Marzano verb-to-level reference |
| DUA guidelines | references/priming-rag/rag-dua-inclusion.md | Yes | DUA principle definitions and adaptation examples |
| Output | Format | Description |
|---|---|---|
| Taxonomy alignment report | Markdown table | Per-activity: declared level, actual level, verdict |
| DUA compliance report | Markdown table | Per-activity: adaptation count, principles covered, verdict |
| Indicator coverage map | Markdown table | Per-indicator: evaluation instrument, status |
| Backward design audit | Narrative + table | Objective-assessment-activity chain validation |
| Summary with severity counts | Statistics block | CRITICAL / WARNING / INFO counts |
## Pedagogical Review — [Unit Name]
**Summary**: [X] findings | [C] CRITICAL | [W] WARNING | [I] INFO
### Taxonomy Alignment
| Activity | Destreza | Expected Level | Verb Used | Actual Level | Verdict |
|----------|----------|---------------|-----------|-------------|---------|
| Act 1.1 | DZ-LENG-5-01 | Analizar | Clasifica | Analizar | OK |
| Act 1.2 | DZ-LENG-5-02 | Evaluar | Lista | Recordar | CRITICAL: Level mismatch |
### DUA Compliance
| Activity | Representation | Engagement | Action/Expression | Total | Verdict |
|----------|---------------|------------|-------------------|-------|---------|
| Act 1.1 | 1 | 1 | 0 | 2 | OK |
| Act 1.2 | 0 | 1 | 0 | 1 | WARNING: Below threshold |
### Indicator Coverage
| Indicator | Evaluation Instrument | Status |
|-----------|----------------------|--------|
| I.LENG.5.1.1 | Rubric U1 | COVERED |
| I.LENG.5.1.2 | — | ORPHAN |
### Backward Design Chain
| Objective | Assessment | Activities | Chain Status |
|-----------|-----------|------------|-------------|
| OBJ-01 | Rubric U1 | Act 1.1, 1.3 | COMPLETE |
| OBJ-02 | — | Act 1.2 | BROKEN: No assessment |
### Remediation Guidance
1. **CRITICAL — Act 1.2 taxonomy mismatch**: Replace "Lista" prompt with an evaluation-level verb (e.g., "Juzga", "Argumenta"). [PEDAGOGIA]
2. **WARNING — Act 1.2 DUA below threshold**: Add a representation adaptation (e.g., graphic organizer alternative). [PEDAGOGIA]
ERROR: Cannot verify taxonomy without references/taxonomy-mapping.md.ERROR: Unit lacks destreza references. Run verify-coverage first.references/pedagogical-review-criteria.md — Backward design checklist, taxonomy verification rules, DUA compliance matrix.references/taxonomy-mapping.md — Bloom/Marzano verb-to-level mapping.references/priming-rag/rag-dua-inclusion.md — DUA principles and adaptation examples.references/priming-rag/rag-pedagogical-framework.md — Pedagogical framework primer.