Validate Components

"Frontmatter is the API contract of a skill. Without it, the runtime cannot discover, route, or constrain."

Validates that every skill, agent, and command file has correct YAML frontmatter, required fields, proper types, and a well-structured body.

---

Procedure

Step 1 -- Enumerate All Components

• Glob skills/*/SKILL.md for skills.
• Glob agents/*.md for agents.
• Glob commands/*.md for commands.
• Record total count per type. If a type directory exists but is empty, report INFO: No <type> found.

Step 2 -- Validate Skill Frontmatter

For each skills/*/SKILL.md:

• Parse YAML frontmatter (content between --- delimiters).
• name (required): Must be a non-empty string. CRITICAL if missing.
• description (required): Must be a non-empty string, ideally >20 chars. CRITICAL if missing, WARNING if <20 chars.
• allowed-tools (required): Must be present and must be a YAML array (not a string, not comma-separated). CRITICAL if missing. CRITICAL if not an array. Valid tool names include: Read, Write, Edit, Glob, Grep, Bash, WebFetch, WebSearch, NotebookEdit, TodoWrite.
• author: INFO if missing (recommended but not required by spec).
• Detect unknown frontmatter keys and report INFO for each.

Step 3 -- Validate Skill Body

For each skill, check the markdown body (content after closing ---):

• Must contain a heading (# or ##) that serves as the skill title.
• Must contain a section with one of: Procedure, Steps, Workflow, Process. WARNING if no procedural section found.
• Should contain at least one numbered or bulleted list. INFO if no lists detected.
• Check for empty body (only whitespace after frontmatter). CRITICAL if body is empty.

Step 4 -- Validate Agent Frontmatter

For each agents/*.md:

• name (required): Must be a non-empty string. CRITICAL if missing.
• description (required): Must be a non-empty string. CRITICAL if missing.
• tools: Should be a YAML list of tool names. WARNING if missing (agents without tool constraints may have unintended access).
• Agent body should contain a role description and at minimum one section describing responsibilities or skills assigned.

Step 5 -- Validate Command Frontmatter

For each commands/*.md:

• description (required): Must be a non-empty string. CRITICAL if missing.
• user-invocable (required): Must be true (boolean). CRITICAL if missing or set to false.
• argument: INFO if missing (commands without arguments are valid).
• alias-of: If present, record for cross-reference validation.

Step 6 -- Detect Duplicate Names

• Collect all name values from skills, agents, and commands.
• Report WARNING for any duplicate name appearing in multiple components.
• Report CRITICAL if the same name appears within the same component type (two skills named identically).

Step 7 -- Generate Components Report

• Produce per-file findings: | Component | Type | Severity | Finding |.
• Summary statistics: total components scanned, pass rate per type, top issues.
• If all components pass required checks: "Component validation PASSED".

---

Quality Criteria

• Every finding references the exact file path and the specific frontmatter field.
• Type validation is strict -- allowed-tools: "Read, Bash" (string) is detected as wrong.
• Body validation does not penalize for creative section naming if procedural content exists.
• Duplicate detection is case-insensitive.
• The report includes per-type pass rates (skills, agents, commands) and a total components scanned count.

Assumptions & Limits

• Read-only. This skill never creates or modifies component files.
• Cannot validate whether a skill's allowed-tools list is appropriate for its procedure -- only checks format and recognized tool names.
• Does not evaluate the semantic quality of frontmatter values (e.g., whether the description is useful), only their presence, type, and format.
• Agent body scanning for "responsibilities" is heuristic -- a creatively structured agent file may pass manual review but fail the heading check.
• Command user-invocable field is validated as a boolean, but YAML parsers accept yes/no/on/off as boolean equivalents -- this skill treats only true as valid.

Good vs Bad

Bad finding:

Missing name in skill.

Missing: no file path, no field name, no expected type.

Good finding:

CRITICAL | skills/validate-hooks/SKILL.md | name | Missing. Expected: non-empty string in YAML frontmatter. | (absent)

Includes: severity, exact file path, field name, expected type, current value.

Anti-Patterns

1. Accepting allowed-tools as a comma-separated string instead of a YAML array.
2. Skipping agent/command validation because "only skills matter".
3. Not detecting frontmatter that uses tabs instead of spaces (YAML spec requires spaces).
4. Treating user-invocable: "true" (string) as valid when a boolean is required.

Edge Cases

1. Skill with frontmatter but completely empty body -- CRITICAL.
2. Command with alias-of pointing to itself -- CRITICAL (circular alias).
3. Agent file with no frontmatter delimiters at all -- CRITICAL.
4. Frontmatter with multiline description using | or > YAML syntax -- valid, do not flag.
5. Extra files in skill directories beyond SKILL.md (templates, examples) -- INFO.