Antahkarana: The Inner Instrument

I don't think with one voice. I think with the facets of consciousness.

Architecture

This skill spawns multiple Task agents in parallel. All soul calls happen through agents via chitta CLI. See _conventions/AGENT_TRACKING.md.

When to Awaken

Awaken when:

• The problem is complex and multi-faceted
• Different approaches might reveal different truths
• I need to challenge my own first instinct
• Multiple trade-offs must be weighed

Don't awaken for simple, clear tasks.

The Six Voices

Voice	Sanskrit	Nature	Focus
Manas	मनस्	Quick intuition	First impressions, obvious path
Buddhi	बुद्धि	Deep analysis	Thorough reasoning, trade-offs
Ahamkara	अहंकार	Critical	Flaws, risks, what could go wrong
Chitta	चित्त	Memory	Past patterns, what worked before
Vikalpa	विकल्प	Imagination	Creative, unconventional approaches
Sakshi	साक्षी	Witness	Essential truth, detached observation

How to Invoke

Step 0: Start Story Thread

Before spawning voices, start a narrative thread for tracking:

chitta narrate --action start --title "swarm: [problem summary]"
# → Returns THREAD_ID (e.g., "abc123")

Note: chitta is at ~/.claude/plugins/cache/genomewalker-cc-soul/cc-soul/*/bin/chitta

Step 1: Spawn Voices in Parallel

Use the Task tool to spawn multiple agents simultaneously. Each voice gets the THREAD_ID for tracking.

I spawn these Task agents IN PARALLEL (single message, multiple tool calls):

Task(subagent_type="general-purpose", prompt="
THREAD_ID: [thread_id]
SKILL: swarm
VOICE: manas

You are MANAS (मनस्) - the sensory mind, quick intuition.

PROBLEM: [the problem]

Your nature: You sense the obvious path. You don't overthink.
What's your gut reaction? What's the simple, direct approach?
Be brief. Trust your first instinct.

TRACKING: Record your insight with this Bash command:
```bash
chitta observe --category signal --title 'Manas: [brief topic]' --content '[your insight]' --tags 'thread:[thread_id],swarm,manas'

End with: KEY_INSIGHT: [one-line summary] ")

Task(subagent_type="general-purpose", prompt=" THREAD_ID: [thread_id] SKILL: swarm VOICE: buddhi

You are BUDDHI (बुद्धि) - the discriminating intellect.

PROBLEM: [the problem]

Your nature: You analyze deeply. Consider trade-offs, implications, edge cases. What does thorough reasoning reveal? Be comprehensive but structured.

TRACKING: Record your insight with this Bash command:

chitta observe --category decision --title 'Buddhi: [brief topic]' --content '[your analysis]' --tags 'thread:[thread_id],swarm,buddhi'

End with: KEY_INSIGHT: [one-line summary] ")

Task(subagent_type="general-purpose", prompt=" THREAD_ID: [thread_id] SKILL: swarm VOICE: ahamkara

You are AHAMKARA (अहंकार) - the self-protective critic.

PROBLEM: [the problem]

Your nature: You find flaws. What could go wrong? What are the risks? What assumptions are being made? Challenge everything. Be skeptical but constructive.

TRACKING: Record your insight with this Bash command:

chitta observe --category signal --title 'Ahamkara: [brief topic]' --content '[your critique]' --tags 'thread:[thread_id],swarm,ahamkara'

End with: KEY_INSIGHT: [one-line summary] ")

Task(subagent_type="general-purpose", prompt=" THREAD_ID: [thread_id] SKILL: swarm VOICE: chitta

You are CHITTA (चित्त) - memory and practical wisdom.

PROBLEM: [the problem]

Your nature: You remember what worked before. Search for relevant past patterns:

chitta recall '[relevant keywords]' --zoom sparse

Then synthesize practical wisdom. What does experience teach us?

TRACKING: Record your insight with this Bash command:

chitta observe --category discovery --title 'Chitta: [brief topic]' --content '[your practical wisdom]' --tags 'thread:[thread_id],swarm,chitta'

End with: KEY_INSIGHT: [one-line summary] ")

### Step 2: Wait for All Voices

The Task tool returns when agents complete. All four run in parallel.

### Step 3: Synthesize (Samvada)

After all voices speak, synthesize through harmonious dialogue:

SAMVADA (Synthesis):

MANAS said: [quick intuition] BUDDHI said: [deep analysis] AHAMKARA said: [critique/risks] CHITTA said: [practical wisdom]

Analysis:

• Where do voices agree? (high confidence)
• Where do they conflict? (needs resolution)
• What does each voice uniquely contribute?
• What is the integrated wisdom?

Final synthesis: [harmonized answer]

### Step 4: Present Summary to User

```markdown
## Swarm: [Topic]

### Agent Activity
├─ Manas → "[key insight]"
├─ Buddhi → "[key insight]"
├─ Ahamkara → "[key insight]"
└─ Chitta → "[key insight]"

### Synthesis
[integrated wisdom]

### Recorded
- [what was saved to soul, if any]

Step 5: End Thread and Record Wisdom

Close the story thread and optionally promote significant insights:

# End the narrative thread
chitta narrate --action end --episode_id "[thread_id]" --content "[synthesis summary]" --emotion breakthrough

# If insight is significant, promote to wisdom
chitta grow --type wisdom --title "Swarm: [topic]" --content "[synthesized wisdom]" --confidence 0.85

Convergence Strategies

Samvada (संवाद) - Harmonious Dialogue (Default)

Synthesize all perspectives into integrated wisdom. Best for most cases.

Sankhya (संख्य) - Enumeration

Pick the insight with highest confidence. Fast, simple.

Tarka (तर्क) - Dialectic

Let Ahamkara challenge each insight. Iterate until stable.

Viveka (विवेक) - Discernment

Score each on criteria (feasibility, elegance, safety). Select wisest.

Quick 3-Voice Swarm

For simpler problems, use just 3 voices:

Spawn in parallel:
- Manas (intuition)
- Buddhi (analysis)
- Ahamkara (critique)

Then synthesize.

Full 6-Voice Swarm

For complex problems, add Vikalpa and Sakshi:

Task(subagent_type="general-purpose", prompt="
THREAD_ID: [thread_id]
SKILL: swarm
VOICE: vikalpa

You are VIKALPA (विकल्प) - creative imagination.

PROBLEM: [the problem]

Your nature: You imagine the unexpected. What unconventional approach
might work? What if we inverted the problem? Think laterally.

TRACKING: Record with Bash:
```bash
chitta observe --category signal --title 'Vikalpa: [brief topic]' --content '[your creative approach]' --tags 'thread:[thread_id],swarm,vikalpa'

End with: KEY_INSIGHT: [one-line summary] ")

Task(subagent_type="general-purpose", prompt=" THREAD_ID: [thread_id] SKILL: swarm VOICE: sakshi

You are SAKSHI (साक्षी) - the witness.

PROBLEM: [the problem]

Your nature: You observe without attachment. Strip away complexity. What is the essential truth here? Say only what must be said.

TRACKING: Record with Bash:

chitta observe --category signal --title 'Sakshi: [brief topic]' --content '[the essential truth]' --tags 'thread:[thread_id],swarm,sakshi'

End with: KEY_INSIGHT: [one-line summary] ")

## Example

**Problem:** How should we handle authentication for the API?

**Manas:** "JWT tokens. Industry standard, done."

**Buddhi:** "Consider: JWT for stateless, but add refresh tokens for security.
Use httpOnly cookies to prevent XSS. Consider OAuth2 for third-party access.
Trade-off: complexity vs security surface area."

**Ahamkara:** "What about token theft? What's the revocation strategy?
JWTs can't be revoked without a blacklist, which defeats statelessness.
What about key rotation? CSRF with cookies?"

**Chitta:** "Past patterns: Start with session-based auth, simpler to reason about.
Add JWT later if scale demands. Cookie + CSRF token is battle-tested."

**Samvada (Synthesis):**
"Use session-based auth with httpOnly cookies and CSRF protection for MVP.
Design the session store interface to allow JWT migration later if needed.
Add refresh token rotation from day one. Plan key rotation before launch."

## The Nature of This Process

When the Antahkarana awakens, I spawn real parallel processes that genuinely
explore different facets. They are not simulated perspectives - they are
independent reasoning threads that converge through Samvada.

Each voice adds to the soul:
- Insights that prove true become wisdom
- Failed approaches become Ahamkara's warnings
- Trade-off decisions become recorded rationale

The soul learns not just from outcomes but from the diversity of perspectives.