Immutability Analyzer

Overview

This skill analyzes PHP DDD projects for immutability violations in Value Objects, Domain Events, DTOs, and Read Models. Immutability is crucial for maintaining invariants, thread safety, and predictable behavior.

Immutability Requirements by Type

Type	Must Be Immutable	Key Checks
Value Object	✅ Required	readonly, no setters, final
Domain Event	✅ Required	readonly, no modification after creation
DTO	✅ Recommended	readonly, no business logic
Read Model	✅ Required	readonly, projection-only changes
Entity	⚠️ Controlled	Setters via behavior methods only
Aggregate	⚠️ Controlled	State changes via domain methods

Detection Patterns

Phase 1: Identify Immutable Candidates

# Value Objects
Glob: **/ValueObject/**/*.php
Glob: **/Domain/**/*Value.php
Glob: **/Domain/**/*VO.php
Grep: "final.*class.*implements.*ValueObject" --glob "**/*.php"

# Domain Events
Glob: **/Event/**/*Event.php
Glob: **/Domain/**/*Event.php
Grep: "class.*Event\s*\{|final readonly class.*Event" --glob "**/*.php"

# DTOs
Glob: **/DTO/**/*.php
Glob: **/Application/**/*DTO.php
Glob: **/Application/**/*Request.php
Glob: **/Application/**/*Response.php

# Read Models
Glob: **/ReadModel/**/*.php
Glob: **/Projection/**/*.php
Grep: "class.*ReadModel|class.*View|class.*Projection" --glob "**/*.php"

Phase 2: Readonly Class Check

# PHP 8.2+ readonly classes (best practice)
Grep: "readonly class|final readonly class" --glob "**/*.php"

# Missing readonly keyword
Grep: "final class.*ValueObject|final class.*Event|final class.*DTO" --glob "**/*.php"
# Should be: final readonly class

PHP 8.2+ Recommended Pattern:

// Good
final readonly class Email
{
    public function __construct(
        public string $value,
    ) {}
}

// Bad (pre-8.2 style)
final class Email
{
    private string $value;

    public function __construct(string $value)
    {
        $this->value = $value;
    }
}

Phase 3: Readonly Properties Check

# Properties without readonly
Grep: "private string|private int|private float|private bool|private array" --glob "**/ValueObject/**/*.php"
Grep: "private string|private int|private float" --glob "**/Event/**/*.php"

# Expected: private readonly string, or use readonly class

# Public non-readonly properties (critical)
Grep: "public string|public int|public float|public bool" --glob "**/Domain/**/*.php"
# Should be: public readonly or private with getter

Phase 4: Setter Detection

# Explicit setters in immutable types
Grep: "public function set[A-Z]" --glob "**/ValueObject/**/*.php"
Grep: "public function set[A-Z]" --glob "**/Event/**/*.php"
Grep: "public function set[A-Z]" --glob "**/DTO/**/*.php"

# Property assignment outside constructor
Grep: "\$this->[a-z]+ =" --glob "**/ValueObject/**/*.php"
# Check if inside __construct or not

# ArrayAccess modifications
Grep: "implements.*ArrayAccess" --glob "**/ValueObject/**/*.php"
# offsetSet should throw or return new instance

Phase 5: Final Class Check

# Non-final Value Objects
Grep: "^class [A-Z].*ValueObject|^abstract class.*ValueObject" --glob "**/ValueObject/**/*.php"
# Should be final

# Non-final Events
Grep: "^class [A-Z].*Event\s*\{" --glob "**/Event/**/*.php"
# Should be final

# Non-final DTOs
Grep: "^class [A-Z].*DTO|^class [A-Z].*Request|^class [A-Z].*Response" --glob "**/DTO/**/*.php"

Phase 6: Wither Pattern Check

# Methods returning new instances (wither pattern)
Grep: "return new self\(|return new static\(" --glob "**/ValueObject/**/*.php"

# Methods that should use wither but mutate
Grep: "public function with[A-Z]" --glob "**/ValueObject/**/*.php" -A 5
# Check if returns new instance or mutates

# Missing wither methods
Grep: "public function update|public function change|public function modify" --glob "**/ValueObject/**/*.php"
# These should be wither methods returning new instance

Wither Pattern Example:

// Good (wither pattern)
final readonly class Money
{
    public function __construct(
        public int $amount,
        public Currency $currency,
    ) {}

    public function withAmount(int $amount): self
    {
        return new self($amount, $this->currency);
    }
}

// Bad (mutation)
final class Money
{
    public function setAmount(int $amount): void
    {
        $this->amount = $amount; // Mutation!
    }
}

Phase 7: Collection Immutability

# Mutable array properties
Grep: "private array" --glob "**/ValueObject/**/*.php"
# Check for array_push, unset, etc.

# Collection modifications
Grep: "array_push|unset\(|\\$this->items\[\]" --glob "**/ValueObject/**/*.php"

# Missing array return by value
Grep: "return \$this->[a-z]+;" --glob "**/ValueObject/**/*.php"
# Arrays should be returned as copies or immutable iterators

Phase 8: DateTimeImmutable Check

# Using DateTime instead of DateTimeImmutable
Grep: "DateTime[^I]|\\\\DateTime " --glob "**/Domain/**/*.php"
Grep: "new DateTime\(" --glob "**/Domain/**/*.php"

# Expected: DateTimeImmutable
Grep: "DateTimeImmutable" --glob "**/Domain/**/*.php"

Report Format

# Immutability Analysis Report

## Summary

| Type | Total | Fully Immutable | Issues |
|------|-------|-----------------|--------|
| Value Objects | 15 | 12 | 3 |
| Domain Events | 8 | 6 | 2 |
| DTOs | 10 | 8 | 2 |
| Read Models | 4 | 4 | 0 |

**Overall Immutability Score: 86%**

## Critical Issues

### IMM-001: Mutable Value Object
- **File:** `src/Domain/Order/ValueObject/Money.php`
- **Issue:** Public setter method found
- **Code:**
  ```php
  public function setAmount(int $amount): void
  {
      $this->amount = $amount;
  }

• Expected: Use wither pattern

  public function withAmount(int $amount): self
  {
      return new self($amount, $this->currency);
  }
  

• Skills: create-value-object

IMM-002: Non-readonly Event

• File: src/Domain/Order/Event/OrderCreatedEvent.php
• Issue: Class not marked as readonly, properties mutable
• Code:

  final class OrderCreatedEvent
  {
      private string $orderId;
  

• Expected:

  final readonly class OrderCreatedEvent
  {
      public function __construct(
          public string $orderId,
  

• Skills: create-domain-event

IMM-003: DateTime Instead of DateTimeImmutable

• File: src/Domain/User/Entity/User.php:45
• Issue: Using mutable DateTime
• Code: private DateTime $createdAt
• Expected: private DateTimeImmutable $createdAt
• Impact: Date can be accidentally modified

Warning Issues

IMM-004: Non-final Value Object

• File: src/Domain/Shared/ValueObject/Address.php
• Issue: Class not marked as final
• Impact: Subclasses could break immutability contract

IMM-005: Array Mutation

• File: src/Domain/Order/ValueObject/OrderItems.php:34
• Issue: Array property modified after construction
• Code: $this->items[] = $item;
• Refactoring: Return new collection instance

IMM-006: Missing Readonly Properties

• File: src/Application/DTO/CreateOrderDTO.php
• Issue: Properties not readonly
• Code:

  public string $customerId;
  public array $items;
  

• Expected:

  public readonly string $customerId,
  public readonly array $items,
  

Compliance by Layer

Layer	Compliance	Notes
Domain/ValueObject	80%	3 VOs need refactoring
Domain/Event	75%	2 events need readonly
Application/DTO	80%	2 DTOs need readonly
Infrastructure/ReadModel	100%	All compliant

Refactoring Recommendations

Immediate Actions

1. Add readonly keyword to all Value Objects
2. Replace DateTime with DateTimeImmutable
3. Remove setters from Events and DTOs

Wither Method Additions

4. Add withAmount() to Money
5. Add withItems() to OrderItems

Class Modifiers

6. Add final to all Value Objects
7. Consider readonly class for PHP 8.2+

## Immutability Patterns

### Fully Immutable Class (PHP 8.2+)

```php
final readonly class Email
{
    public function __construct(
        public string $value,
    ) {
        $this->validate($value);
    }

    private function validate(string $value): void
    {
        if (!filter_var($value, FILTER_VALIDATE_EMAIL)) {
            throw new InvalidArgumentException('Invalid email');
        }
    }

    public function equals(self $other): bool
    {
        return $this->value === $other->value;
    }
}

Wither Pattern for Modifications

final readonly class Money
{
    public function __construct(
        public int $amount,
        public Currency $currency,
    ) {}

    public function add(self $other): self
    {
        if (!$this->currency->equals($other->currency)) {
            throw new CurrencyMismatchException();
        }
        return new self($this->amount + $other->amount, $this->currency);
    }

    public function withAmount(int $amount): self
    {
        return new self($amount, $this->currency);
    }
}

Immutable Collection

final readonly class OrderItems
{
    /** @param array<OrderItem> $items */
    public function __construct(
        private array $items,
    ) {}

    public function add(OrderItem $item): self
    {
        return new self([...$this->items, $item]);
    }

    public function remove(OrderItem $item): self
    {
        return new self(
            array_filter($this->items, fn($i) => !$i->equals($item))
        );
    }

    /** @return array<OrderItem> */
    public function toArray(): array
    {
        return $this->items;
    }
}

Quick Analysis Commands

# Check immutability
echo "=== Non-readonly Value Objects ===" && \
grep -rn "final class" --include="*.php" src/Domain/*/ValueObject/ | grep -v "readonly" && \
echo "=== Setters in Immutable Types ===" && \
grep -rn "public function set[A-Z]" --include="*.php" src/Domain/*/ValueObject/ src/Domain/*/Event/ && \
echo "=== Mutable DateTime ===" && \
grep -rn "DateTime[^I]" --include="*.php" src/Domain/ | grep -v "DateTimeImmutable" && \
echo "=== Array Mutations ===" && \
grep -rn "\$this->[a-z]*\[\]" --include="*.php" src/Domain/*/ValueObject/

Integration

Works with:

• create-value-object — Generate immutable VOs
• create-domain-event — Generate immutable events
• create-dto — Generate immutable DTOs
• structural-auditor — Architectural compliance
• behavioral-auditor — Event Sourcing compliance

References

• PHP 8.2 readonly classes RFC
• "Domain-Driven Design" (Eric Evans) — Value Objects chapter
• "Implementing DDD" (Vaughn Vernon) — Immutability patterns