superpowers-sage:modeling

Modeling — Content Architecture Analysis

Classify content within blocks and components to determine the right data modeling approach: static ACF fields, dynamic CPTs, Options Pages, or relationship fields.

When to use

• Planning a new block or component that displays content
• Deciding whether content should be hardcoded, editable per-page, or managed as a collection
• Before implementing blocks to prevent "static content that should be dynamic" mistakes
• Automatically invoked by /building when content classification is needed

Content Classification Matrix

Classification	When to Use	Implementation
Static	Fixed text that rarely changes, part of page identity	ACF field in block fields()
Dynamic Collection	Growing list of items (portfolio, team, testimonials)	CPT via Poet + taxonomy
Dynamic Global	Shared across pages (site info, social links, CTA)	ACF Options Page
Dynamic Relation	References other content (featured posts, related projects)	ACF Relationship field
Fixed Repeater	3-5 items, rarely change, no detail pages	ACF Repeater field in block

Decision Checklist

For each piece of content in a block, ask:

1. Does this content appear in more than one place?

   • YES → Dynamic Global (Options Page) or Dynamic Relation
   • NO → Continue...

2. Will the client add/remove items over time?

   • YES → Dynamic Collection (CPT)
   • NO → Continue...

3. Does the list have categories or filters?

   • YES → Dynamic Collection (CPT + taxonomy)
   • NO → Continue...

4. Is it a fixed set of 3-6 items that rarely changes?

   • YES → Fixed Repeater (ACF Repeater in block)
   • NO → Continue...

5. Does this content have its own detail page?

   • YES → Dynamic Collection (CPT) — even if the list is short
   • NO → Continue...

6. Should this content be searchable or filterable on the frontend?

   • YES → Dynamic Collection (CPT)
   • NO → Static (ACF field)

Output Format

For each analyzed component, output:

### Content Model: {Component Name}

| Content Element | Classification | Implementation |
|---|---|---|
| {element} | {static/dynamic-collection/etc.} | {ACF field type / CPT name} |

**Poet Config** (if CPTs needed):
```php
// config/poet.php
'post' => [
    'project' => [
        'route' => 'projects',
        'supports' => ['title', 'editor', 'thumbnail'],
    ],
],
'taxonomy' => [
    'project_type' => [
        'links' => ['project'],
        'meta_box' => 'radio',
    ],
],

ACF Fields (key fields):

$this->addText('headline', ['label' => 'Headline']);
$this->addRepeater('items', ['label' => 'Items'])
    ->addText('title')
    ->addTextarea('description')
    ->endRepeater();

Query Example (if dynamic):

$projects = get_posts([
    'post_type' => 'project',
    'posts_per_page' => 6,
    'orderby' => 'menu_order',
    'order' => 'ASC',
]);

## Key Principles
- **Ask the checklist** — don't guess, systematically evaluate each content element
- **Default to static** — only use CPTs when the checklist clearly indicates dynamic content
- **YAGNI** — a repeater is simpler than a CPT; use the simpler option when both work
- **Poet for CPTs** — never `register_post_type()` directly
- **Future-proof wisely** — if content will "probably" grow, use a CPT; if "maybe someday", use a repeater

## Query First — MCP Integration

Before proposing CPTs or ACF field groups, query what already exists:

execute-ability posts/list-types execute-ability acf/field-groups

See [`sageing/references/mcp-query-patterns.md`](../sageing/references/mcp-query-patterns.md).