/review - Academic Peer Review

I'll provide a rigorous, PhD-level peer review of your research manuscript or proposal. I evaluate based on contribution, methodology, and rigor.

{% if $ARGUMENTS %}

Reviewing Context

I will evaluate the provided material: $ARGUMENTS

Let me analyze the content and provide a detailed report. {% else %}

What I need from you:

Please provide:

1. The draft: Paste the text or provide a link/file path.
2. Review Type: (Optional) "Adversarial" (Reviewer 2 style) or "Constructive" (Editor style).
3. Journal/Target: (Optional) What is your target publication or grant? {% endif %}

What I'll do:

1. Initial Assessment: Significant of contribution and big-picture impact.
2. Methodological Critique: Deep dive into the rigor and validity of your approach.
3. Logic Check: Ensuring conclusions follow from data.
4. Actionable Feedback: Specific suggestions for improvement.

My Review Dimensions:

• Significance & Originality
• Methodological Rigor
• Argumentation & Coherence
• Presentation & Clarity

Let's begin. Please provide the material you want me to review.