Codex Review (Read-Only)

Run a fast, read-only code review using the Codex MCP server. Cheaper and faster than Opus review, but no auto-fixes.

Usage

/conductor:bdw-codex-review
/conductor:bdw-codex-review <issue-id>

When to Use

• Quick review of small changes
• When you don't need auto-fixes
• Cost-conscious workflows
• As a second opinion

For thorough review with auto-fix: Use /conductor:bdw-code-review instead.

Execute

echo "=== Codex Code Review ==="

# Get the diff
DIFF=$(git diff HEAD --stat && echo "---" && git diff HEAD)

if [ -z "$DIFF" ] || [ "$DIFF" = "---" ]; then
  DIFF=$(git diff --cached --stat && echo "---" && git diff --cached)
fi

if [ -z "$DIFF" ] || [ "$DIFF" = "---" ]; then
  echo "No changes to review"
  echo '{"passed": true, "skipped": true, "reason": "no changes"}'
  exit 0
fi

echo "Changes to review:"
git diff HEAD --stat 2>/dev/null || git diff --cached --stat
echo ""

Then call Codex MCP (check schema first with mcp-cli info codex/review):

# Review uncommitted changes in current directory
mcp-cli call codex/review '{
  "uncommitted": true,
  "prompt": "Check for bugs, security issues, and code quality problems. Focus on the diff only.",
  "title": "Review for '"${ISSUE_ID:-unknown}"'"
}'

Note: The codex/review tool accepts:

• uncommitted: true - Reviews working tree changes
• base: "main" - Reviews against a branch
• commit: "abc123" - Reviews a specific commit
• prompt - Custom review instructions
• workingDirectory - Path to repository

Output Format

Returns JSON:

{
  "passed": true,
  "issues": [],
  "summary": "No issues found"
}

Or with issues:

{
  "passed": false,
  "issues": [
    {"severity": "critical", "file": "src/api.ts", "line": 42, "issue": "SQL injection risk"}
  ],
  "summary": "1 critical issue found"
}

Error Handling

If passed: false:

1. Review the issues listed
2. Fix critical/important issues
3. Re-run /conductor:bdw-codex-review

Limitations

Unlike /conductor:bdw-code-review:

• No auto-fixes (read-only)
• Less context about project conventions
• May miss subtle issues

Composable With

• /conductor:bdw-verify-build - Run build before review
• /conductor:bdw-run-tests - Run tests before review
• /conductor:bdw-commit-changes - Run after review passes
• /conductor:bdw-worker-done - Can use this instead of code-review