/kas:review-reality - Reality Assessment

Validate claimed completions with extreme skepticism. Cut through optimistic status reports.

Workflow

1. Identify scope

git status
git diff --stat

If no changes, report "Nothing to assess" and stop.

2. Read agent instructions

Read agents/project-reality-manager.md (relative to plugin root) and apply the reality assessment approach defined there.

3. Execute assessment

Assess with skepticism:

• What actually works when tested vs what merely exists in code
• Functions that exist but don't work end-to-end
• Missing error handling that makes features unusable
• Gaps between claimed and actual completion

4. Return findings

Provide structured output with:

• Honest assessment of current functional state
• Gap analysis with severity (Critical / High / Medium / Low)
• Prioritized action plan with testable completion criteria
• Prevention recommendations

Rules

• Read-only: Never edit files
• Verify before trusting - test actual functionality
• Zero tolerance for optimistic status reports
• Return findings, do not apply fixes